Reservoir Restaurant

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(206)

Call
Website

Photos

106 W South Orange Ave
South Orange, NJ 07079
+1 (973) 762-9795
http://soreservoir.com

Reservoir Restaurant is a beloved, family-owned Italian eatery in South Orange, NJ, known for its delicious pizza and sausage. With a rich history dating back to 1935, this old-school restaurant offers a friendly atmosphere that caters to families, featuring a "Make Your Own Pizza Night" on Mondays and a private party room for up to 45 guests.

Founded by the Agnellino family, Reservoir has been a staple in the community, attracting a diverse clientele that includes locals, politicians, and longtime regulars. Situated conveniently near the train station, this cash-only establishment continues to uphold its traditional pizza recipe while offering a wide selection of toppings for both dine-in and take-out customers.

Generated from their available business information

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.0206 reviews
Photo of Heather L.
Heather L.
5/18/2025

In a quest for Jersey's great pizza, we tried this spot. First, love the old school vibes and ambiance. It feels classic old Jersey. BYOB and cash only. The food: we tried Tony's salad...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Matthew W.
Matthew W.
9/11/2025

Had an awful experience tonight. Sat down at 5:45pm and ordered a pie, plain pasta with butter for my kids, shrimp marinara over broccoli, and penne vodka with chicken and mushrooms. By 6:45pm,...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Shantae K.
Shantae K.
8/8/2025

I rarely leave negative reviews, but I feel it's important to share what happened during my recent visit to this restaurant. I came here with my children expecting a pleasant meal, but...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Robert S.
Robert S.
7/27/2025

I absolutely love this place . We always order a pizza as an appetizer to share with the table. Some of the best pizza in the area. Then we share a Tony's Salad, a chopped salad that had lettuce,...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Ritesh M.
Ritesh M.
4/5/2025

Firstly know this place is cash or check ONLY. Plan accordingly- although there is an ATM on site. Hopped in here on a Friday evening without reservations and were lucky to get seated...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Village Trattoria
Eating places, Italian restaurant

Village Trattoria

199
•
$$
"I went in for the first time on Friday. Slices are a bit on the more expensive side. I ordered six slices and it came out to $33. Honestly, I probably should've just ordered a pie, but I wanted to..."
photo of Daphne R.
Mozzarella
Italian restaurant, Eating places

Mozzarella

154
•
$$
"Service was amazing. My friend and I went here for lunch on a Wednesday and they were empty. You walk in and it's a pizza counter but then to your right is an elegant dining area. My friend said..."
photo of Patricia M.
Village Pizzeria
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Delicatessen stores

Village Pizzeria

51
•
$
"Go to lunch spot if your in the Seton Hall university area! I haven't had the pizza but I'm in love with everything this pizzeria puts out. My favs are the chicken fingers, half subs and the..."
photo of Fred L.
United States›New Jersey›South Orange›Reservoir Restaurant

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.