John G.
10/10/2023
Some months ago I posted a review based on my concerns over the changes in the food and the inexperienced servers. We didn't stop going there because we understood that they were still impacted by...
Pizzaiolo By Brothers
$$
Closed
(237)
Photos
85 Godwin Ave
Midland Park, NJ 07432
Pizzaiolo By Brothers, located in the heart of Midland Park, NJ, has proudly served the community for 45 years, specializing in fine Southern Italian cuisine. The restaurant is known for its classic preparations, generous portions, and commitment to using the freshest quality ingredients.
With a rustic farmhouse setting, Pizzaiolo By Brothers offers a family-friendly dining experience featuring a variety of seating options, including traditional and communal styles. Guests can enjoy outdoor dining from April through October and a diverse menu of homemade dishes designed to please every palate.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
2.5237 reviews
Brianna S.
10/10/2025
I'm really disappointed, and I can't give this place more than a single star. We went with a group of 4 toddlers and 3 adults, hoping for a simple meal. We wanted to order a large pizza for the...
Andrew T.
10/10/2025
Pizza place. Pizza is in the name. Yet we come to find out they don't serve large pies for dining in after 4pm. Place is empty at 5:30 on a Friday and they wouldn't consider an exception for a...
Kevin C.
10/29/2025
Terrible delivery service.The owner doesn't care if his driver is late or unable to communicate effectively.The driver called a second time for directions. We refused delivery.
Joseph S.
10/6/2025
Never will go there again. I ordered a pickup their website said it was ready. I went they didn't know what I was talking about. They said it wasn't ready. All the time it was sitting on top of...
See a problem?
