Mike S.
5/30/2025
Iv been coming here since they opened! Always the best!! Never once had a bad experience! Well done fella's!
Pizza Mania
$
Closed
(172)
Photos
390 Midland Ave
Garfield, NJ 07026
PizzaMania has been serving Garfield, N.J. and the surrounding neighborhoods and towns since 1998, when Gaetano Buttitta took over the store on Midland Avenue. In addition to great regular traditional pizzas and specialty Pizzas we also offer many authentic Italian dishes, made to order, using the freshest ingredients around. We are pleased to also be able to cater our customers parties and special events.
Reviews
3.5172 reviews
Christine I.
6/30/2025
This has been a long time coming review from a few months ago: Ordered 6:51 online estimated delivery 7:51 Received a Call at 7:49 to say he is here - I said your not and kept giving the...
Randi P.
8/28/2024
Once again an incredible meal! Huge portions. Delivered in minutes and very fresh and hot. We got two meals out of it. Loved the specials!
Lisa B.
1/26/2025
I love this pizzaria. They make terrific pizza. Trust me on this. A lot of places make specialty pies, and people like them because they are different, but they do them very very well here, and...
George B.
1/27/2025
I got the pizza wings and soda special. The pizza was good, had the perfect amount of sauce to cheese ratio. When it comes to the wings you get a mix of some meaty drums and barely anything on it...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.