Kristy C.
8/17/2025
Long lines for a reason, I find myself crawling back here again and again for some pie, scones and galettes. Everything here is baked fresh for the day and the changing menu keeps things...
Pie Girl
$
Closed
(27)
Photos
117 W Ward St
Hightstown, NJ 08520
Pie Girl, located in Hightstown, NJ, has been delighting pie enthusiasts for eight years with its unique farm-fresh creations. The offerings include inventive flavors such as salted honey lavender, chocolate-covered strawberry, cranberry chess, and sweet Jersey corn custard.
Renowned for her homemade yet elevated pies, Chelsea Frosta has garnered praise from notable figures, including James Beard award semifinalist Matthew Rosenzweig. His favorites include the grapefruit chess pie, apple crumb pie, and rustic chocolate pie, which are available at his bakeshop in Shrewsbury, NJ.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.527 reviews
Alivia D.
2/22/2025
Pie Girl knows what she's doing while whipping up her incredible pies. I love the whole concept of a weekly rotating menu, and it seems that each item is perfectly curated. The way to go is...
Leena S.
1/3/2025
Pie Girl is a quaint little venue only open limited hours on Fridays and Saturdays. Essentially open until everything is sold. The selection of sweet and savory pies is extraordinary and...
Ben R.
2/1/2025
Heard some great things about Pie Girl so stopped by on Saturday - only open Friday & Saturday 10:00-2:00. Located on a side street off Main St in a restored building (plenty street parking)....
Kelly S.
6/14/2025
My friend got a pie and was talked into an expensive franken pie, it looked horrible with missing crust when she went back she was told rudely that's what it's supposed to look like I'll never go...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.