Rod T.
3/21/2025
Best NJ tomato pie. Completely underrated. I bring friends from out of state and they say the same thing. The sauce is very flavorful with the right amount of cheese which isn't too thick. The...
Pete's Pizza
$
Closed
(104)
Photos
2919 Route 206 Ste 104
Columbus, NJ 08022
History
Al and Elizabeth Stefan started Kate & Al's Pizza in 1957, in a little corner at the Columbus Farmers Market. Over the years they moved the business across the hall into a bigger space.
Specialties
We do our best to deliver the best pizza around by using only the finest ingredients. We make everything from scratch. We grind our own cheese. We take pride in our business
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0104 reviews
Samantha F.
2/3/2025
So I won't lie the location of the pizza place didn't give me the most hope because it's most definitely not a modern appearance... but don't let that sway you... the pizza was phenomenal...it's...
Carrie S.
1/12/2025
This is now on my regular rotation when I'm in the mood for thicker crust. The sauce is flavorful and can stand on its own. It's a thick layer but the crust holds up to it. It's not your...
Tom S.
3/27/2025
The pizza is similar to Pete's but I like the pizza here because it's a bit more saucy. The customer service is friendlier here hence the 5 stars. Definitely will be back!
Alyssa M.
6/25/2025
Seriously incredible pizza. Just the right amount of crispiness and thickness in the crust with delicious sauce and a soft cheese pull. Top notch!!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.