Leah T.
7/25/2025
I wish I had taken a picture but we ate them so fast it was impossible! These take the term "ice cream sandwich" to a new level. The team onsite works so quickly so don't be deterred if there's a...
Peace Pie
$
Closed
(258)
Photos
326 Carpenters Ln
Cape May, NJ 08204
Established in 2015. I still remember coming home from college for Thanksgiving in 2008. Walking into my father's house in Woodstock, he said, "Joe, you aren't going to believe what I just made." (I've learned to become concerned when he says those words) "I took your pecan pie, put it on top of a shortbread cookie in a large baking tray, and covered it all with ice cream! I call it 'Pecan Pie a la Mode Lasagna!'" My less than enthusiastic response quickly changed after I tried a piece. And that's how it began. Six years later, the lasagna has become hand-sized portions, and is being produced and sold by the thousands (they also picked up a better name along the way). We know you'll enjoy them as much as we do! See you soon, Joe
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5258 reviews
Kaitlin E.
8/2/2025
Stopped by Peace Pie in Cape May and tried the Peanut Butter Brownie ice cream sandwich. The flavor was incredible--rich, indulgent, and packed with the perfect combo of peanut butter and...
Kate F.
7/16/2025
Thankfully you don't know the ingredients when you are at the shop but we happened to grab some from the freezer at our hotel and I was SHOCKED. This is not ice cream. It is pure chemicals with a...
Lee E.
8/25/2025
It's delicious! My wife and I had the banana cream and an apple pie (?). My only gripe is there's no north jersey location
Cindy M.
10/14/2024
This Cape May gem is an ice cream shop that will visit for years to come. The small shop has a cool walk up window. The ice cream sandwich is tasty and tons of cool flavors to choose from. I'll...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.