Average
6/2/2024
Pizza was bland and we asked for it to be baked "regular" - not well done - still well done. Friend...
Papa's Tomato Pies
$
Closed
(149)
Photos
19 Robbinsville Edinburg Rd
Robbinsville, NJ 08691
Papa's Tomato Pies, established in 1912, proudly holds the title of the oldest continuously family-owned pizzeria in the United States. Known for their unique 'Mustard Pie' and classic tomato pies, they have become a beloved institution in Robbinsville, NJ, offering a wide variety of pizzas, appetizers, entrees, and salads.
The restaurant is famous for its commitment to traditional Italian flavors, featuring well-cooked pies with a slight char, customizable toppings, and a selection of both classic and innovative dishes. From hearty pasta options to delectable desserts, Papa's Tomato Pies aims to provide a satisfying dining experience for all pizza enthusiasts.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.5149 reviews
Calls themselves Papa's Tomato Pies But Don't know What a Tomato Pie Is.
7/11/2023
Ordered a Tomato Pie for Pick up and received a Burned Round Pizza Pie. Called to discuss and was to...
Try the mustard!
12/28/2022
Went to Papa’s with business acquaintance while on a work trip and was looking for something “local”...
See a problem?
