Rich W.
9/16/2025
Papa's and nearby DeLorenzo's both serve very good tomato pies, but Papa's are honestly just a little more to my liking than DeLorenzo's pies. To me, the sauce at Papa's stands out a little more,...
Papa's Tomato Pies
$$
Closed
(467)
Photos
19 Robbinsville Allentown Rd
Trenton, NJ 08691
Papa's Tomato Pies is a long-standing pizzeria in Trenton, NJ, known for its traditional tomato pies.
Established in [year], the restaurant offers a variety of toppings on its thin-crust pizzas, catering to both locals and visitors.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0467 reviews
Michele S.
9/2/2025
Had this on my list of places to try. Didn't realize they were famous for their mustard pie. Was hoping to try a slice but they only offered it as a pie. We did get their traditional pie and...
Thomas A.
8/30/2025
8/23/25 - Pre-gaming took place at a restaurant called Papa's Tomato Pies in Robbinsville, NJ. They market the place as the oldest tomato pie restaurant in the country as it was opened in 1912....
Chris E.
7/24/2025
Another check on our pizza pilgrimage checklist and JUST AS GOOD AS ADVERTISED. Papa's is located at a small, quiet strip mall and we arrived on the day after July 4th at around 1PM. Even though...
Dolly C.
7/5/2025
- Thin, crispy pizza with tons of sauce. Good flavor, but a bit too crunchy. - Soft drinks aren't watered down but come full of ice and no free refills. - Toddler friendly with plenty of high...
See a problem?
