Sarah C.
7/2/2025
Our first time here and it was amazing! We got espresso martinis, pork lollies, the grouper and the braised short rib. Everything was delicious and cooked perfectly. Wish we had room for dessert....
Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar
$$$
Closed
(312)
Photos
615 Lafayette St
Cape May, NJ 08204
Situated in the charming coastal town of Cape May, NJ, Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar stands out as a seafood lover's paradise. With its prime location near the Atlantic Ocean, this dining spot prides itself on serving up the freshest catches of the day, ensuring a true taste of the sea in every dish.
From succulent oysters on the half shell to perfectly grilled fish entrees, Oyster Bay offers a diverse menu that celebrates the bounty of the ocean. The relaxed yet elegant ambiance makes it an ideal setting for a leisurely meal with friends or a romantic dinner for two, where you can savor each bite while soaking in the coastal vibes of this seaside gem.
Generated using this place's available information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0312 reviews
Gillen J.
10/30/2025
Excellent HAPPY HOUR w dollar oysters! Attentive and kind bartender charged my phone for me when my aunt and I enjoyed a dozen oysters EACH! Nice happy hour drink specials. Very pretty inside and...
Helene T.
8/23/2025
We have dinner at Oyster Bay every trip to Cape May. The atmosphere is relaxing; the staff is friendly; and the food is great. I like the nod to a traditional night out for dinner!
Sara B.
10/9/2024
Kind of a weird / old school vibe. We sat outside which was a mistake. There was absolutely zero atmosphere, and service was not great. The menu is small and we were also a little disappointed to...
Aly W.
11/13/2024
It wasn't bad but it wasn't great which is why I have to give 3 stars. The place is very cute, I like the old nautical feel it has. I think the menu overall is great and very gluten free friendly!...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.