Charlie S.
6/7/2025
So happy to found this little bagel shop and my bagel breakfast made my day great. Also people there were so nice which makes all customers smile. I'll try for my lunch next time and I'm...
Old Time Bagels
$
Closed
(36)
Photos
3253 State Route 35
Hazlet, NJ 07730
Old Time Bagels, located in Hazlet, NJ, has been a beloved establishment at Chelsea Place for over eight years. Known for their hand-rolled bagels made with the freshest ingredients, they also offer coffee, newspapers, lottery tickets, and Boar's Head sandwiches to cater to a variety of tastes.
The owner, Hal, takes pride in providing solid competition to neighboring Dunkin Donuts, offering a unique selection of breakfast options that set them apart in the area. With a focus on quality and variety, Old Time Bagels continues to be a popular choice for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from their available business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.536 reviews
Wendy P.
10/10/2025
Nice mom and pop bagel shop. They were both nice and efficient. Our egg sandwiches were good.
Evan G.
10/27/2025
No complaints. Service was good and food was good. I ordered a breakfast sandwich and it was fairly priced and tasted good. Bagels are good.
Alexis B.
12/14/2024
We have been on the hunt for good bagels near hazlet and have fell short every time. This place was a big no for us. Not just for taste and food but customer service as well. No one was friendly...
C M.
7/7/2025
Quality bagels with your classic pleasant chew. Exterior has crisp bubbles that are as aesthetically pleasing as they are indicative of the quality. Flavorful. Shop is small and run by an old...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.