Brian F.
7/6/2025
Nicky G's Pizza is one of my regular spots for solid, tasty pizza. The pies are always good--crispy crust, generous toppings, and a nice balance of sauce and cheese. But honestly, this review...
Nicky G's
$
Closed
(43)
Photos
4 Colfax Ave
Pompton Lakes, NJ 07442
Nicky G's is a cozy eatery in Pompton Lakes, NJ, offering a variety of classic Italian dishes and pizzas.
With a casual atmosphere and friendly service, Nicky G's is a popular spot for locals looking for a satisfying meal.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.043 reviews
Julie P.
12/28/2024
Mid sized pizza spot with plenty of seating, went in for a quick slice but they only had plain slices left. Appears their pies are made when ordered. The have in house sodas which was crisp and...
Kasia C.
8/1/2024
My favorite pizza in town! We always get the Grandma's Pie and a large cheese pizza, with a side of the garlic knots. The Grandma's Pie is perfection - the right amount of cheese, sauce and...
Wendy D.
7/18/2025
Delicious, definitely recommend . Good crispy crust, great sauce. Definitely one of the best pizzas in the area
Vickie C.
9/12/2025
First time ordering. Portions were great. Sauce also very good. I ordered eggplant parm entree with a side of spaghetti and a meatball sandwich. I wish they used the plastic containers...
See a problem?
