Kyra F.
9/1/2025
10/10 bagels. I got a bacon egg and cheese, and a half a dozen to bring home. The sandwich was perfect, crispy bacon melt cheese, and a perfectly crispy outside soft inside bagel. I'd say they...
New York Water Bagel Co
$
Closed
(108)
Photos
542 Fischer Blvd
Toms River, NJ 08753
New York Water Bagel Co specializes in offering a variety of bagels. The establishment aims to provide a unique bagel experience that attracts both locals and visitors alike.
Despite mixed feedback on customer service, the bagels remain a highlight for many patrons. The company has a loyal following, with some customers looking forward to their visits on weekends.
Generated from the web
Also at this address
Reviews
3.0108 reviews
Patricia M.
7/20/2025
One word: wow! Was down in Seaside Heights with family for a week and we got bagels from here three times. I got the Asiago herb bagel all three times. The melted cheese in the middle had me sold....
Marylin M.
8/29/2025
I work in Seaside Heights. I live in brick. I'v gone to a bunch of bagels places in the area. This is just convenient on the way in to work. I've been their a handful of times once again they do...
Phil P.
10/11/2025
Quick in and out...the aromas are amazing. Absolutely the best bagels in TR and the area. Love their Porkroll egg and cheese sandwich's too!
Andres L.
3/9/2025
to think that I almost canceled my order because did not have delivery drivers available at 6:45 in the morning. My gut instinct told me otherwise, so I had my lazy booty get in my truck to make...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.