Nelwin D.
6/6/2025
Stopped by Neil Pizzeria after hearing some good things, and overall, it was a nice experience. We tried the Classic Buffalo Chicken pizza, the Arugula Special, and an order of French fries. The...
Neil's Pizzeria
$
Closed
(114)
Photos
568 Valley Rd
Wayne, NJ 07470
Neil's Pizzeria in Wayne, NJ, is celebrated as the community's go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine and mouthwatering pizza, boasting over three decades of dedicated service. With a focus on quality, all dishes are prepared fresh to order using the finest ingredients, ensuring a delightful dining experience.
As a BYOB establishment, Neil's Pizzeria invites guests to enhance their meals with their own beverages in a welcoming and genuine old-world atmosphere. The restaurant offers flexible catering options for events of all sizes, making it an ideal choice for both casual meals and special gatherings.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.5114 reviewsBill T.
9/29/2025
ANOTHER BURNT BLACK PIZZA! See pictures from last review. Last couple pizzas were ok after complaining. But now they're burning the bottom black again. I mean really. What the hell is wrong...
Eric W.
9/16/2025
Still one of the best pizzerias in Wayne ! And there are plenty of them. There specialty slices can't be beat. I always enjoy the vegetable or spinach . Fresh garlic knots are always good too.
Waldem
5/21/2025
The best pizzeria in Wayne, good service, good food and good atmosphere very clean and with a variety of dishes
Debi M.
5/29/2025
Pizza was nice and hot right out of the oven. Staff was friendly and the place was spotless. We always get our pizza and antipasto's there. Highly recommended!!!!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.