M.B. W.
11/18/2025
The employees are very nice & the atmosphere is laid back. The food is so good! I ordered lunch & also got takeout from their Magical Market.
My Kitchen Witch Cafe
$$
Closed
(288)
Photos
29 Beach Rd
Monmouth Beach, NJ 07750
History
After 9/11 Karyn began to reconsider her decision to base her business in NYC and in 2005, she returned to the Jersey shore to open My Kitchen Witch Cafe. Here, her philosophy has blossomed: healthy choices and top-quality ingredients -- blended with a little bit of magic -- make for a spellbinding combination.
Specialties
Delicious breakfast, brunch and lunch items including our famous bacon. Unique and whimsical witchy decor. Great location near the Shore in beautiful Monmouth Beach. A Magical Market open every day until 7:00 p.m. where you can buy full dinners for $8.95 or get cooked food by the pound. Also offering a juice bar and a daily kettle soup.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0288 reviewsDiana R.
10/5/2025
We love the breakfasts at My Kitchen Witch! We haven't yet tried lunch or dinners but heard they're great too! Whenever we're in town; either Sea Bright, Red Bank, Long Branch or anywhere else in...
Cindy K.
9/23/2025
Love the food and this place. I think the inside needs a facelift and painting. Exhaust fans would be great for the aroma in the place. I do prefer outdoor dining. Just a suggestion
Grace S.
10/8/2024
After writing my review for My Kitchen Witch, the owner, Karyn responded to me immediately upon reading it. She was apologetic and there's no doubt she takes pride in her establishment. Whenever...
Barbara S.
8/25/2025
Service could use improvement, they don't have a system for seating people. Menu says the French toast is "extra thick", and when you get the order, it's literally two slices of bread the size of...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.