Mayer's Tavern

$
Closed
yelp logo

(123)

Photos

894 3rd Ave
Cape May, NJ 08204
Lively restaurant and bar located on Spicer Creek in Cape May. Serving local seafood, quality burgers, and more alongside handcrafted cocktails and a unique wine list. A favorite of locals and tourists alike since 2018.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.0123 reviews
Photo of Mallory B.
Mallory B.
8/12/2025

We were seated quickly upon arrival, which was a great start. The atmosphere inside was lively, though a bit too loud--made it difficult to hold a conversation at times. We started with the...

Photo of Libby B.
Libby B.
6/21/2025

I had no idea a place can change so much in a year! Mayer's now serves up more attitude than anything else. The food has taken a significant dive since last season (no longer serve their homemade...

Photo of Nancy W.
Nancy W.
4/5/2025

So happy you're open again ! We had a delightful meal here as always. The chicken liver mousse appetizer was spectacular! Hubby had the scallops which are always fresh and cooked to perfection....

Photo of Adam S.
Adam S.
8/19/2025

Food good despite shrinking portion sizes. Aloof attitude from staff. They don't even answer the phone and seem to take pride in that.

Photo of Ashley S.
Ashley S.
7/19/2025

Great food and service. Had the calamari - while it needed more citrus - the squid was tender and flavorful. Cocktails 10/10. Chicken entree was phenomenal- tender and well balanced. Kale Cesar...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew JerseyCape MayMayer's Tavern

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.