Matthews Seafood Market

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(86)

Photos

206 Mechanic St
Cape May Court House, NJ 08210

Matthews Seafood Market is a local gem located in the heart of Cape May Court House, NJ, offering a wide variety of fresh seafood options. Whether you prefer to have their expertly cooked catches or bring home their seafood and prepared foods for a convenient meal, Matthews has something for everyone. In addition, during the summer months, they even provide fresh produce sourced from local farms, ensuring the highest quality ingredients.

With pristine ingredients and a reputation for serving some of the best expertly shucked local oysters, Matthews Seafood Market has become a go-to destination for seafood lovers. Their unique market concept has garnered praise from renowned food critic Craig LaBan, making it a place worth revisiting. Whether you're looking to place an order for a special occasion or have your fish vacuum-sealed, Matthews is dedicated to providing exceptional service and ensuring customer satisfaction.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.586 reviews
Photo of Dana R.
Dana R.
5/2/2025

Every year we come to Cape May we order at least a couple of dozen - or so - fresh shucked New Jersey oysters to take back to our cabin for sunset dining. This year they had only the NJ Betsy's -...

Photo of Marc K.
Marc K.
8/20/2025

A nice charming small place. Takeout or "eat in" (which is same as takeout menu, with service and waitstaff). Service was friendly and swift. Had the steamed mussels which were good with a light...

Photo of Lana S.
Lana S.
9/29/2025

Local fish market where you can buy raw or prepared seafood and prepared salads. They also have table service on the outdoor patio and it is byob. Food is fresh, well prepared, and reasonably...

Photo of Lisa D.
Lisa D.
9/28/2025

What a wonderful seafood market! Fresh, delicious seafood offerings and helpful customer service!

Photo of Julia B.
Julia B.
9/10/2024

This seafood store/restaurant combo is tucked away right in the heart of Cape May Courthouse - if you blinked you would miss it! The outdoor patio restaurant seating is super cute & decorated with...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew JerseyCape May Court HouseMatthews Seafood Market

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.