Kashmir S.
9/18/2025
I had used this bakery to deliver pastries for my sons birthday. The delivery driver delivered to wrong house. The person that worked with me to rectify the issue was very helpful and went above...
Mattarello Bakery & Cafe
Open
(66)
Photos
254 Bellevue Ave
Montclair, NJ 07043
Specialties
We specialize in Italian pastries, cookies and cakes. We serve exceptional coffee and coffee drinks. Expect every morning a fresh homemade soup and a quiche to enjoy. We offer custom cakes for birthdays, celebrations and special occasions. Stop by and enjoy the delicious treats!
Also at this address
Reviews
4.566 reviews
Melissa L.
10/26/2025
We asked if a pastry contained nuts because our child has a nut allergy. They said it was nut-free. It was full of Nutella. They swapped it for a cookie, but didn't even apologize. The desserts...
Ognjenka Z.
2/23/2025
Very cute bakery in upper Montclair and tbh they have a lot of coffee choices as well . I wanted a coffee and something sweet so stopped by here . I got the hazelnut cake and a Nutella coffee . My...
Politia M.
12/29/2024
Nice, cozy bakery with coffee and pastry options. They also sell some Italian products such as pasta, cookies and coffee beans. The pastries are fresh and soaked in a nice syrup that kept the...
Nerissa H.
7/17/2024
First, this will be my second 5-star review mainly because I LOVE LOVE LOVE this coffee, bakery, and cafe! They recently started brunch from 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. How amazing is that!?!?...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.