Henry D.
9/1/2025
Best TRENTON Tomato Pie in south jersey. It should be since the owner once worked at DeLorenzo's the best tomato pie place in Trenton. Thin crust that doesn't droop, tasty chunks of rich...
Mateo's Tomato Pie & Restaurant
Closed
(50)
Photos
New Jersey Ave # 38
Hainesport, NJ 08036
Mateo's Tomato Pie & Restaurant, located in Hainesport, NJ, offers a menu that highlights their signature tomato pies among a variety of other dishes. The establishment prides itself on providing quality food in a welcoming atmosphere for its patrons.
Situated at 1509 Route 38, Mateo's is committed to delivering a satisfying dining experience. With a focus on delicious flavors and customer satisfaction, the restaurant has become a local favorite in the community.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.050 reviews
Betty Jo T.
11/11/2025
Mateos special steak sandwich was delicious. Green peppers mushrooms and onions. I opted no cheese (don't need it)
Steve J.
9/10/2025
Finally got to try Pizza from here after seeing all the reviews. I'm not a tomato pie fan, but I figured I'd try the other pizzas and toppings. The lump sausage is amazing and very flavorful. They...
Louis G.
9/14/2024
My wife and I took a nice Saturday morning backroads drive to LILO Tomato Pizza only to find them closed due to their participation in the David Portnay One Bite Pizza Festival in Randalls...
Staci W.
8/1/2024
Great cheesesteak and tomato pie! One of our favorite local spots to get great pizza. Their cheesesteak was meaty and great flavor!
See a problem?
