Vin D.
9/8/2020
I first found out about this place from someone who said this was the 'Springers' of Sea Isle City. Oddly enough my family lives there and I had never been here or was aware of it's...
Marita's Homemade Ice Cream
$
Closed
(57)
Photos
64O1 Landis Ave
Sea Isle City, NJ 08243
Marita's Homemade Ice Cream is a beloved family-owned and operated ice cream shop located in Sea Isle City, NJ. Since 1987, they have been serving up delicious homemade ice cream, earning accolades such as "Best of the Shore" by Philadelphia Magazine and South Jersey Magazine, as well as "Best of Sea Isle" by Beachcomber Magazine.
Known for their mouthwatering flavors and friendly service, Marita's Homemade Ice Cream has become a staple in the community, attracting both locals and tourists alike. In addition to their delectable menu, they are also dedicated to giving back, with their 'Cones for a Cure' initiative raising an impressive total of $62,210.90 for cancer research. With 37 seasons of proudly serving Sea Isle City, Marita's Homemade Ice Cream is a must-visit destination for ice cream enthusiasts.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.057 reviews
Jonathan B.
7/29/2025
First, my lord this is overpriced for mediocre store-bought ice cream. Second, their service is awful. They misunderstood my young son when he ordered (totally fine) but when he politely asked...
j r.
6/29/2025
Used to be good. $20 for two ice creams that weren't even filled to the top. Girl said sprinkles compressed it down. Same thing as my wife's with no sprinkles. Save your money and go...
Raiden K.
6/14/2025
Might be the worst ice cream I've ever had at the jersey shore y'all. Took one bite and was immediately displeased. Must've been in the freezer for 12 months. No wonder there was no line. Also,...
Cindy E.
6/27/2025
This place is an absolute disgrace. The prices are outrageous and the portions are so small. This place should be closed down they are a complete rip off and how they treat middle class families...
See a problem?
