Cindi W.
5/24/2019
Once again... Superb! This place does it all. Delicious food with a decently wide selection served by friendly, capable people. Still Highly Recommended!
Manhattan Bagel
$
Closed
(55)
Photos
1933 Highway 35
Belmar, NJ 07719
Manhattan Bagels are made fresh in-store every day the classic NY-style way – boiled and baked with love.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.555 reviews
Steven P.
10/11/2025
I've been to this location numerous times. What's disconcerting is even though they advertise their hours as 6AM to 2PM, they shut down the grill at 1:10PM or earlier. Which means, if you want...
Joi D.
8/2/2025
Tasteless, bready bagels and tepid coffee. One bright spot is that they do have real butter on their bagels.
Frank M.
7/13/2025
Was much better before the change in mgmt a couple years ago. As for bagels, the bagels themselves are still good but they are very skimpy on the cream cheese, just a thin layer now. Better to buy...
Angelina P.
1/20/2025
Our Go to bagel spot! Nestor always waits on us with a smile. Their bagel sandwiches rock! The French toast bagels and honey wheat everything are wonderful
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.