Michele S.
8/5/2025
Great new addition to Montclair. Went on a cold and rainy Thursday night. Pretty quiet inside but lots of pick up orders coming in and out. Ordered the Detroit pie which was really...
Maker Pizza
Open
(9)
Photos
171 Forest St
Montclair, NJ 07042
Maker Pizza is a vibrant neighborhood eatery in Montclair, dedicated to offering handcrafted pizzas made from scratch with the freshest local ingredients. With a commitment to bold flavors and warm hospitality, it serves as a welcoming spot for both classic and innovative pizza lovers.
Rooted in tradition yet inspired by the diverse community of Montclair, Maker Pizza aims to bring people together through exceptional food and genuine connections. Whether guests are indulging in a classic Margherita or one of the restaurant's creative signature pies, they can expect a cozy atmosphere perfect for unwinding.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.59 reviews
Danielle J.
8/2/2025
Overall solid pizza spot. Greeted as soon as we came in, order was taken promptly, & suggestions were made (fresh pies for slices were in the oven) Pizza was had good flavor even though I don't...
Christine G.
7/9/2025
Great casual pizza shop. In the middle of a residential area so it was fun to watch patrons walk, bike and scooter in. Went to dine in and food took awhile to come out. They are still trying to...
Dena H.
10/6/2025
We were in the area and tried Maker Pizza and ordered a couple of slices. We weren't a huge fan of the pizza. Maybe the pies are different when you order it fresh.
David G.
8/29/2025
Pizza in the $20 and up range had better be good, especially when a good Jersey slice is so available, but what "artisanal" pizzerias offer are fresher ingredients, and sometimes that matters. It...
See a problem?
