Derek B.
8/8/2025
I've had bagels all over New York and New Jersey, and Island Heights Bagelry easily ranks among the best I've ever had. The bagels are perfectly fresh, with that ideal balance of a crisp exterior...
Island Heights Bagelry
Closed
(6)
Photos
214 W End Ave
Toms River, NJ 08753
Island Heights Bagelry located in Toms River NJ is a cozy eatery known for its fresh delicious bagels and inviting atmosphere. This local gem offers a variety of bagel flavors spreads and toppings making it the perfect spot for a quick breakfast or lunch. With friendly service and a commitment to quality Island Heights Bagelry is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Generated from this place's information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.06 reviewsMary N.
5/29/2025
Best bagels in the area! What a great surprise when we first tried them. Will definitely be a regular customer!
Barbara D.
6/15/2025
Beat bagels and great sandwiches. Easy to get to. Right off rt. 37 in Island Heightsgreat
Megan D.
3/28/2025
So happy this place opened up!! We tried a pork roll, egg and cheese on a bagel, a french toast muffin and a chicken cheesesteak and everything was AMAZING!! Will definitely be back.
John L.
3/4/2025
Compared to the NY water bagle store on fisher , these bagels don't compare . Was hoping for a great bagel but it's just ok
See a problem?
