Anonymous U.
10/4/2025
This place is the perfect breakfast spot! You can tell the bagels are homemade from the taste and the look! They are so fresh and soft and flavorful! They had a good mix of unique bagel flavors...
Hackettstown Bagels
Closed
(44)
Photos
333 Mountain Ave
Hackettstown, NJ 07840
Hackettstown Bagels is a popular deli in Hackettstown, NJ, known for serving the best bagels in town. With a wide variety of fresh bagel options, as well as delicious deli sandwiches and homemade salads, customers can satisfy their cravings for breakfast or lunch. The deli also offers party bagels and catering services for special occasions, and regularly provides different monthly coupons as a token of appreciation to its patrons.
Owned by Joe Nicastro and Mary Lalama, and managed by Troy Livesey, Hackettstown Bagels is a go-to destination for bagel lovers. Located at 333 Mountain Avenue, this deli is open seven days a week, from 5 AM to 2 PM, ensuring that customers can enjoy their favorite bagels any day of the year. With its commitment to quality ingredients and a drive-thru option for convenient pick-up, Hackettstown Bagels is a must-visit spot for a satisfying breakfast or lunch experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.044 reviews
Jon F.
8/29/2025
Being new to this area and loving bagels, I was really excited to try this place. I went in around 5am before work and immediately noticed how clean and up to date everything was. I ordered a...
Ally C.
10/25/2025
Well...I've tried this place a few times. So far it's been pretty terrible. The order is wrong every single time if you order by phone. It's wrong 95% of the time when placed inside the cafe....
Steve I.
6/20/2024
@BigDudesBigFoods was in #HackettstownNJ today to check out a new AND an old #SmallBusiness located on the same property. First we stopped at @HackettstownBagels for #BreakfastSamiches and met a...
James Z.
8/28/2024
This is an update. As happy as I used to be coming here there have been some changes. Mostly with staff. Yes, they are friendly and know me on a first name basis but the new people have had enough...
See a problem?
