Cathryn H.
7/13/2025
Delicious food. Nice portions. Like the ravioli and the white spinach pies. My family likes the sausage and broccoli raab.
Gencarellis of Lyndhurst
$
Open
(149)
Photos
552 New York Ave
Lyndhurst, NJ 07071
Gencarelli's of Lyndhurst has been delighting the Lyndhurst community with the finest authentic Italian cuisine since 2009. With a commitment to using the freshest quality ingredients and a meticulous attention to preparation and detail, Chef Robert Ustica has elevated Italian dining in New Jersey, offering consistently fantastic food.
Customers rave about the amazing atmosphere, personal service, and generous portions at Gencarelli's. Whether enjoying their delicious pizza or indulging in their hearty entrees that come with pasta, salad, and garlic bread, guests are never disappointed. Gencarelli's is a phenomenal dining spot that guarantees an enjoyable experience for all.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5149 reviews
Miranda M.
9/25/2025
Honestly three stars are generous. Pictures are deceiving. Exhibit A B and C included. You could definitely find better but it's not the worst I've had. Some garlic knots were either old or not...
Liz R.
1/15/2025
Was in the area and in the mood for pizza so decided to stop in to Gencarellis for a slice. The place has a lot of tables for dining in and a long pizza counter with various pies. Since it was my...
Kenny W.
10/18/2025
The chicken parm sandwich was terrible. The roll, the chicken, the sauce, everything was just bad. With so many quality pizza places in the area, they won't get a second chance. I gave them 2...
Elizabeth A.
4/2/2025
Growing up, my grandmother often ordered from the Gencarellis Pizza on Bloomfield Ave in Newark. I am unsure if this location is a chain or if they just moved. Great spot! Their pizza has a crispy...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.