Alexis R.
11/9/2025
Great pizza and usually quick delivery! A fan favorite from our house is the bacon chicken ranch, but we love a simple plain pie or pepperoni from here.
Formaggio's Pizzeria
$
Closed
(22)
Photos
36 Main St
Madison, NJ 07940
Formaggio's Pizzeria in Madison, NJ, is a destination for authentic Brooklyn-style Italian cuisine, offering a diverse menu that includes traditional Italian entrees and gourmet pizzas made with the freshest ingredients. The casual and inviting atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for families and friends to enjoy a meal together.
In addition to dine-in options, Formaggio's provides catering services suitable for both intimate gatherings and corporate functions, ensuring a memorable culinary experience for all guests. The establishment values its patrons, offering exclusive savings and tailored offers to enhance the dining experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.522 reviews
Drew O.
12/11/2024
We hit up this joint recommended by my yelp bro Bill aka the Godfather of Hanover aka the Taco King. Drunken Grandma pie was awesome. Great flavor. Needed 3 more mins in the oven. The chopped...
Shane C.
11/15/2024
A great spot to have in town that also delivers. We love getting the eggplant parm and the salads from here. What sets Formaggios apart is their customer service. Recently, we placed an order...
Luis R.
9/21/2024
Was fiendishly looking for pizza while walking around and I am so happy I found this place. I haven't enjoyed a slice of pizza like this in a long time. My son really enjoyed his slice and he's...
Bill M.
11/14/2023
Formaggio's is serving up some seriously delicious Pizza ova'here and they're making their slices so freakin BIG that it doesn't even fit on a plate. Now THIS is what I'm talkin bout people!!...
See a problem?
