Jerry C.
8/3/2025
First order on a Sunday. Had the Old Fashioned Pizza. The salt overpowered the pizza. Pretty disappointing
Coniglio's Old Fashioned
$
Closed
(255)
Photos
11 South St
Morristown, NJ 07960
Coniglio's Old Fashioned in Morristown, NJ, is the brainchild of Nino Coniglio, a Brooklyn-born pizza maker with a legacy of championship victories, including ten titles at the World Pizza Championships in Italy. Known for his exceptional creativity and traditional techniques, Nino has garnered recognition as a prominent figure in the pizza-making world, competing on the Food Network's Chopped and winning the title of Chopped Champion.
Committed to using only the freshest and highest-quality ingredients, Nino Coniglio aims to share his passion for pizza with the local community, continuing a tradition of excellence cultivated over years of experience. His dedication has not only made him a beloved pizza artisan but has also led to his successful ownership of several pizzerias in Brooklyn.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.0255 reviews
Loanne N.
7/31/2025
Stopped by here while I was in the area and so glad I did! Cute casual but lovely interior with seating indoor and outdoor. You order at the front and can seat anywhere in the restaurant. If...
Dena H.
7/27/2025
Come for the pastries or the pizza, you can't go wrong! This is my first time dining at Coniglios and I'll definitely be back! If you're coming for pizza, it's best to come with 2+ people since...
Erin H.
6/24/2025
I visited Coniglio's Old Fashioned for a casual family meal while visiting downtown Morristown. We ordered the Brooklyn Round pie, and the pizza was excellent. The crust and dough had a really...
Megan Z.
3/16/2025
Updated review a couple of years and many visits later: this was five stars on our first try, but unfortunately I have to take a star away for lack of consistency from this place. The round pies...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.