Cape May Peanut Butter Company

"Peanuts, Peanuts, yes you're my girl Love you and I'll never let you go" (The Four Seasons) While visiting the Nauti Spirits Distillery in Cape May, we spent some time browsing in their...

Underwhelmed by their peanut butter cookie. It was hard. I expected a softer fresher tasting cookie. Bought some natural peanut butter. Looking forward to having that.

Their hours may need to be updated because we just went on a Tuesday and they were definitely open. I read a lot of reviews of Cape May telling me to go here. I like peanut butter, but I really...

A quaint, conveniently located gem in the heart of downtown Cape May. We walked in and were greeted immediately and were offered samples of their newest peanut butters, as well as their classics....

This is such a random store to love but we do. We had walked by it a couple days in a row and finally decided to go in. Worth it! We tried so many delicious things and walked away with about...