Rudolph P.
9/28/2025
Was in town dropping off a load at the USPS down the street and me and my co-driver decided to walk and grab something to eat. We stumbled upon this bakery and asked for a Jersey delicacy and was...
Buttercups Bake Shoppe
$$
Closed
(63)
Photos
450 County Road 519
Stewartsville, NJ 08886
History
Buttercups Bakery is a wholesome traditional bake shop specializing in gourmet cupcakes, cakes, cookies, muffins, pies, jams and jellies. They use only the freshest ingredients such as real butter, eggs, sugar and whole milk, predominantly sourcing locally from New Jersey. Everything is baked fresh every morning in small batches to ensure a homemade taste in every bite. Founder Cara Anastasio, has been baking since she was 16 years old. Before opening Buttercups, she worked with a local dairy store as their head baker. Cara wants each baked good to taste as though you are eating a 'Slice of Heaven'. Check out the menu for full listing of goodies. Contact us today for our custom made to order options!
Specialties
Buttercups Bake Shoppe is responsible for bringing delectable bake goods, delicious jams, and fun bake-at-home kits to the Warren County area of New Jersey.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.063 reviews
Ken S.
7/20/2024
Better pastries Lower prices More friendly employees behind counter Brighter and fun atmosphere. So dull and uninviting inside
Karl H.
5/1/2022
Just a little info. Don't know why the name changed. But everything else inside seems the same. Just popped in for ricotta cookies. Yum
Erin C.
1/27/2024
I ordered cupcakes for a luncheon I was hosting. Not only were my interactions with the bakery beforehand, like ordering and communicating design wishes, positive and helpful- but my guests raved...
Hannah K.
6/3/2021
Great cupcakes and other bakery items (my brother loves their chocolate chip cookies). They also do great custom order cakes. A woman-owned business and a small shop, love to support!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.