Andrew P.
9/27/2025
a group of seven went there Saturday night, from the minute I walked in I felt at home, Brooklyn, Italian, family.... thank you Peter, Donna and Amanda and all. food was great, recommendations...
Brooklyn Square Pizza
$$
Closed
(501)
Photos
265 S New Prospect Rd
Jackson, NJ 08527
Do you want traditional Italian pizza made with fresh ingredients and classic recipes? Are you looking for a local pizzeria that offers a wide variety of Italian favorites? Come to Brooklyn Square Pizza in Toms River, Manalapan Township or Jackson Township, NJ for a pizzeria experience with personality. We combine the true mom and pop pizza experience with years of pizza-making technique to create a pizza that's worth talking about.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0501 reviews
Les R.
9/29/2025
Great experience! Authentic in every way. I did a slice of cheese pizza and a slice of their Vodka pizza. Service was friendly and delivered on the old school, small business vibe that is an...
Nikko A.
6/2/2025
Got Brooklyn Square pizza to go and I was thoroughly impressed with my experience. The pizza shop is clean and you can tell it's the real deal as soon as you walk in. The employees were super...
Tim S.
4/13/2025
Awesome square pizza here! Great crust and flavorful sauce. Just the right amount of cheese. They make fantastic round pizzas as well, but go with the square. You won't regret it!
Mario S.
4/6/2025
Always good service and the quality of the squares is second to none. The owner is a real gentleman. Milo gives a 5 paw rating
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.