Brooklyn Pizza

$
Open
yelp logo

(19)

Call
Website

Photos

258 Main Ave
Stirling, NJ 07980
+1 (908) 350-8036
https://brooklynpizzerianj.com

Brooklyn Pizza in Stirling, NJ, is a beloved establishment known for its authentic pizzeria offerings. With a commitment to quality, it stands as a favorite spot for locals seeking delicious pizza made with fresh ingredients.

As part of the All American Pizzeria family, Brooklyn Pizza aims to provide a satisfying dining experience for all its patrons. Whether you're grabbing a slice on-the-go or enjoying a meal with friends, this pizzeria promises a taste of New York right in your neighborhood.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
3.519 reviews
Photo of Paarin M.
Paarin M.
7/28/2018

Got our first taste of this newish place in town. Was hoping to find a home run pizza place that was super close and reasonably priced. We got a plain pie to start. First impressions are the...

Read more on Yelp
Grace T.
6/4/2020

I ordered before from here and thought their pizzas were so so. They advertised get 10% off if you use the clover app, so I ordered from here. Give them another chance. When I went to pick up the...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Nancy S.
Nancy S.
1/28/2018

We ordered a large pie with sausage and extra cheese. The flavor was excellent but the cheese was layered inconsistently. One side was dry and the other had a lot of cheese. They were very busy so...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Barry B.
Barry B.
6/28/2018

One bite everyone knows the rules. I got a sorry ass takeout slice the other night. I was pretty disappointed. LOTS of grease, hardly any flavor. On par with Dominoes if you asked my honest...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Josh T.
Josh T.
2/18/2018

I was torn on whether or not to give this place two stars. I went back and forth pondering whether it would just be an emotional decision because, comparatively to the ghosts of Main Avenue past,...

Read more on Yelp
Owner verified
See a problem?

You might also like

The Station - Bernardsville
Eating places, Bars and lounges, Bar (drinking places)

The Station - Bernardsville

158
•
$$
"Very Welcomin! had the most amazing and fresh ahi tuna sliders with cabbage slaw and ginger sauce AND paid less for the amount of tuna and the delicious add ons than I would have for just the..."
The Brick Oven
Eating places, Italian restaurant

The Brick Oven

164
•
$$
"Thank you for taking a walk in family. My wife loved the ambience the feeling of family and definitely the food. Thank you again, one can sense the good vibes emanating from within."
photo of Niel P.
Pavesi Ristorante
Eating places, Italian restaurant

Pavesi Ristorante

140
•
$$
"Met up with friends there on a Friday based on their recommendation, and everything was delicious and served in nice portion. The service was friendly and pretty fast. The only part that's..."
photo of Lan T.
United States›New Jersey›Stirling›Brooklyn Pizza

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.