Neil B.
9/30/2025
Date of Visit: August 1, 2025 This was my first stop when I got to Cape May and I wasn't disappointed. And I have to agree with Eddie 9, I checked the reviews and the ones that gave it a bad...
Blue Moon Pizza
$
Closed
(118)
Photos
425 Beach Ave
Cape May, NJ 08204
Blue Moon Pizza was established in 2009. It was first started to make pizza for our customers. Over the years the business grew and became much more than a pizzeria. We now serve Burgers, Appetizers, Sandwiches, and Italian dinners.On top of that we also have gluten free options. We have gluten free pizza, wraps, and pasta. We love serving our customers and we would love to have you stop by at 425 beach ave Cape May, New Jersey.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.0118 reviews
Lexie K.
8/6/2025
$36 for 4 slices, salad, and 2 sodas. A bit pricey for the quality imo. Pizza was good thin crust. Salad was good, nice Caesar flavor dressing. The young girl working could not have been less...
Eddie 9.
10/12/2025
Blue moon continues to be the best pizza in Cape may, for being in Cape may 14 years this place has the love it takes in the food the staff of this establishment. Despite any negative naysayers...
Chakhay S.
7/2/2025
Pizza is mid. Tastes like raw dough. Also it boasts generous toppings but there was 6 tiny pepperoni on the whole slice. When I ordered wings and they got it wrong they made me bring it back in...
Steve W.
7/17/2025
ABSOLUTELY horrible experience. Came from a day hot off the beach and was really craving a good Italian Hoagie. This should be a staple for ANY pizza place. Got the food back to our room and...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.