Danielle V.
7/31/2020
Have been ordering here for the last 6 months and it's now our go to go pizza, dinners, cheesesteaks, salads and sandwiches. Everyone in the family proclaimed best local cheesesteak! Delivery is...
Benny's Pizza & Subs
$$
Closed
(30)
Photos
103 State Route 71
Spring Lake, NJ 07762
Benny's Pizza & Restaurant is a beloved, family-owned pizzeria nestled in Spring Lake Heights, NJ since 1985. Serving up delectable pizzas and authentic Italian fare, this cozy establishment caters to both locals and visitors alike. The welcoming ambiance ensures a pleasant dining experience for families and friends.
With a commitment to quality ingredients, Benny's Pizza prides itself on offering a menu filled with mouthwatering dishes. Their friendly staff adds to the inviting atmosphere, making every patron feel right at home. Whether you choose to dine in or opt for delivery, expect your food to arrive promptly and piping hot.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
3.530 reviews
Gloria P.
7/8/2025
Absolutely the worst pizza I've ever had anywhere so called Italian made with underripe ordinary sliced tomatoes. I suggest they not try to imitate Italian style pizza
Linda K.
7/26/2025
The rudest service. I love it here just to start out with. The best buffalo calamari ... always happy eating in and take out. Never an issue til tonight. Didn't even heat up a slice of pizza for...
Stephen M.
3/27/2023
Been coming here for years but very disappointed lately. Ever since Covid, this place has been doing great but now they're fat, happy and greedy! I ordered a sandwich in the store. With no one...
G M.
12/31/2023
I took my 83 year old aunt for a ride to the shore and stopped by Bennys for a slice of Sicilian pizza and panini. It was delicious! I even bought the remaining slices to take back to...
See a problem?
