Johanna E.
5/22/2025
Great Food! Amazing Coffee! Local Gem! Fast Service! Maybe in the near future a place to sit.
Bagel Cafe
$
Closed
(121)
Photos
1292 Springfield Ave
New Providence, NJ 07974
Bagel Cafe NJ is a local coffee and bagel shop with two locations in downtown New Providence and Fanwood, NJ. They offer an elevated experience with hand-rolled bagels, locally roasted coffee, and small batch pastries from Brooklyn.
At Bagel Cafe NJ, all bagels are made on-site through a process of hand-rolling, water boiling, and baking. Their lunch menu features unique signature sandwiches made with bread from their old world bagel recipe. With a focus on quality and freshness, they also offer freshly squeezed orange juice and green juice to complement your order.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.5121 reviews
Lux S.
11/16/2025
Ordered some bagels and found a hair baked into one of the bagels. Normally this place is very clean and reliable but I'd prefer if they paid more attention to the bagel making process.
Steph W.
4/13/2025
Clean and spacious. Has a back and front door, great for cold and raining days. Tried cinnamon raisin bagel, toasted with butter. My typical bagel for new places, did not disappoint but not as...
Cindy C.
5/10/2025
Oh, my! Only the BEST Avocado Toast in the world. Just love this café. I can always count on a positive experience, delicious food, and excellent service. Wow!!!!!!!!!
Bruce S.
5/11/2023
Unfortunate trip to Bagel Cafe today. Ordered a tuna salad on bagel with lettuce and tomato. "We just ran out of lettuce ". Ordered a light roast coffee. As its being poured "just ran out of light...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.