Steve Y.
11/6/2025
White pie with vegetables is excellent. Service is always friendly when getting takeout. Garlic parm wings are also very good.
Anthony's Restaurant & Pizzeria
$
Closed
(78)
Photos
857 Mill Creek Rd
Manahawkin, NJ 08050
Anthony's Restaurant & Pizzeria, located in Beach Haven West, New Jersey, is a beloved local establishment known for its fresh, hot pizzas. With a diverse menu featuring over a dozen types of pizzas, including classics and specialty options like Buffalo Chicken Pizza, it has been a favorite destination for both locals and visitors for decades.
In addition to pizza, Anthony's offers a variety of other menu items including hot and cold subs, appetizers, salads, and entrees, ensuring there is something for everyone. The restaurant prides itself on its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction in a welcoming atmosphere.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.078 reviews
Bina P.
8/27/2024
The pizza here is so good. Crust is perfectly thin and very tasty. We have also tried the chicken cheese steaks which are delicious. This pizzeria deserves 5 stars, every time we come in service...
Pat D.
8/20/2025
The chicken wings was so salty after the second one I had to throw it out and the chicken parm was not good , the sauce was so sour your ears pop.
Robert M.
7/25/2025
Previously the best Pizza around. Now, the large pie is noticeably smaller than it used to be, flop jallops aka no crisp, and cold by the time you get it home. I was a big fan of this shop, so it...
Lauren G.
9/2/2023
Frozen Ellios pizza heated in a microwave is higher quality pizza. Trust me. Tomato paste- that's not sauce! Little to no seasoning. Go margarita pizza- the cheese was uncut & rubbery, why would...
See a problem?
