Doug M.
9/25/2025
Great meatballs. Pasta is wonderful but the pizza is the best. Sometimes we just pick up a slice on the way home and the best is a large one with your custom topping. Spaghetti is great. We have...
ElMar's New York Pizza
Open
(243)
Photos
15725 37th Ave N
Minneapolis, MN 55446
El Mar's New York Pizza is a popular pizzeria located in Plymouth, MN, offering a menu that includes delicious New York-style pizza and bagels.
With a focus on quality and authenticity, El Mar's New York Pizza is known for its mouthwatering pizza and freshly baked bagels, providing a taste of the Big Apple in the heart of Minnesota.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5243 reviews
Victoria L.
6/16/2025
If you're craving a true New York-style pizza experience in the Twin Cities, El Mar Pizza in Plymouth is a hidden gem worth checking out. The moment you step inside, the vibe transports you...
Robert W.
5/29/2025
Growing up in New York and moving to Minnesota after college, I have long been searching for some good New York style pizza. Minneapolis has some great pizza options: Young Joni, Rosalia,...
Ingi E.
9/21/2025
This place has the best NY style pizza I've tried in MN! I've had it for take out a few times and it's been great every time. Recently tried their pickle pizza and it was delish! Thicker slices of...
Nancy W.
9/27/2025
We ordered two slices (Pep & Sausage + Sausage/Shroom/Onion) of pizza. We opted to get pizza by the slice and a beverage. The service was quick and a great fast casual spot. I loved that the...
See a problem?
