Bailey P.
8/29/2025
It was a tough decision between ice cream and a milkshake. The shake won this time around but I'm sure I'll be back sometime soon for some ice cream. The are supposedly famous for their...
Nancy's
Permanently closed
(81)
Photos
142 N Whittaker St
New Buffalo, MI 49117
Nancys at the Lake in New Buffalo, MI is a charming lakeside destination that offers a relaxing atmosphere for visitors to enjoy. With a focus on providing a comfortable and welcoming experience, Nancys at the Lake is a popular spot for those looking to unwind by the water.
Whether you're seeking a peaceful retreat or a fun-filled getaway, Nancys at the Lake caters to a variety of preferences with its serene surroundings and inviting ambiance. Guests can expect a delightful stay at this lakeside haven in New Buffalo.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.581 reviews
Amy F.
7/26/2025
As you walk up, you'd think that this was just another ice cream shop. But, it's far from it! From the decoration to the ice cream. Everything is well thought over. We ordered the triple scoop in...
Isabelle M.
7/18/2025
Quick service and great prices! I got a Chicago style hotdog, delish! My husband got a cheeseburger, delish! And we got milkshakes. My husband got the famous strawberry shake and we can see why it...
Marissa C.
10/5/2024
We kept seeing Nancy's on the way to the beach and knew we needed to stop by. The ice cream mural on the side of the building is so awesome and eye-catching! You walk up to order from the windows,...
Stefanie W.
8/24/2024
My kids wanted sorbet but I am a sucker for coffee ice cream in a waffle cone, so that's exactly what I planned to order. I double backed to Nancy's, unsure where or what to do... when I...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.