Cindy U.
8/16/2025
We had the Italian stallion takeout. It was very good. Half size was good enough for two people, but it was so good. I wish I had more. Service was polite. Ambiance was ok.
Mackinac Island Pizza
Closed
(25)
Photos
1547 Cadotte Ave
Mackinac Island, MI 49757
Mackinac Island Pizza is the island's only Detroit-style pizza shop, specializing in freshly made pan pies that capture the unique essence of Detroit pizza. Their signature offerings feature a crunchy yet light crust and caramelized cheese edges, created daily in authentic deep dish square pans.
In addition to a diverse menu of square pans and signature pies, Mackinac Island Pizza invites customers to join their loyalty program, Mackinac Insider, which offers exclusive perks and memorable experiences at various participating locations. The dedication to quality and community engagement makes this establishment a standout dining option on Mackinac Island.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.025 reviews
Karen L.
5/9/2025
Pizza was great, service and price not so much. When we got in line to order the food, my husband was 3rd in line. It took him about 10-15 minutes to get to the front of the line. For some reason...
connie a.
9/28/2025
The Italian stallion is delicious. It can run with NYC quality of pizza. Service is really nice, and there's tons of seating. It's also open super late
Anu K.
6/9/2025
We initially asked to do half mushroom and half pepperoni but they said they couldn't do it. Seeing from previous posts they clearly do but refused when we asked. The pizza tasted pretty good but...
Lori Z.
10/3/2025
Excellent service and food. Very nice atmosphere. Definitely would eat here again. Best deep dish pizza on the island
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.