Casey's New Buffalo

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(349)

Call
Website

Photos

136 N Whittaker St
New Buffalo, MI 49117
+1 (269) 469-6400
http://caseysnewbuffalo.com

Casey's New Buffalo offers a delightful dining experience in the heart of New Buffalo, MI. Specializing in steaks, seafood, and a vibrant bar atmosphere, Casey's is a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.

Guests can explore a diverse menu showcasing the best of land and sea, prepared with care and expertise. The restaurant also caters to private events, providing a charming setting for gatherings and celebrations.

Generated from the website content

Reviews

yelp logo
3.0349 reviews
Photo of Serene L.
Serene L.
5/22/2025

First the patio is dog-friendly, it's spacious with many tables and beautiful place to hang out when the weather is great My poke bowl was huge! I couldn't finish, probably only ate ¼ of the...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Dan D.
Dan D.
8/12/2025

This place has bad service but okay food. The "famous" chip and dip is just a bowl of sour cream and cold potato chips. I usual like to write more in reviews but that really does sum it up and...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Chris M.
Chris M.
10/29/2025

Pretty good experience overall. Not many customers, they're all probably at Stray Dog. Solid food and drinks.

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Darryl G.
Darryl G.
8/24/2025

My wife and I had lunch today (08-24-25). There was live music (starting at 1:00 pm) that was pleasant. Great atmosphere on the back patio. The staff was polite and playful. I had the Blackberry...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Chris C.
Chris C.
5/17/2025

We stopped at Casey's for a casual date night. After reading the menu we decided to just order a bunch of appetizers. The drunken scallops, chips and dip, crab cake and pork belly tacos all hit...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Hummingbird Lounge
Eating places, Bars and lounges, Bar (drinking places)

Hummingbird Lounge

81
•
$$
"We had such a fun time dining here, the cocktails are all amazing and so unique, the food is great for small bites or a full meal, and the staff are some of the sweetest people. If you have the..."
photo of Alexa C.
Rocks Lounge
Eating places, Bar (drinking places)

Rocks Lounge

4
•
$$$
"Another great band. But what's the deal with old white men in sunglasses? One is dancing all over the floor with his female companion. I mean all over the floor and even out in the casino. The..."
photo of Paul S.
City Lanes
Bars and lounges, Bowling equipment and supplies

City Lanes

11
"My family and I always have fun when we go. Although we were very disappointed in the fact that they changed their pizza recipe. They use to have the best pizza in Michigan city, now it's like all..."
United States›Michigan›New Buffalo›Casey's New Buffalo

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.