Brewster's Italian Cafe

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(510)

Photos

11 W Merchant St
New Buffalo, MI 49117
A locally owned restaurant located in downtown New Buffalo, Michigan; Brewster’s New Buffalo puts a contemporary spin on traditional Italian fare, along with creative, globally inspired dishes. While we're rooted in Italian cuisine, our palette expands far beyond the borders of Italy.

Reviews

yelp logo
4.0510 reviews
Photo of Tom M.
Tom M.
6/9/2025

We've been here quite a few times in the past but this time was Breakfast. Wow, they really fixed up the place, looks like a few more outside tables. This time we sat in the atrium because we...

Photo of Selma L.
Selma L.
5/17/2025

Our favorite place to eat when visiting New Buffalo. Our 3 year old liked it so much, he asked to eat here twice on this trip. Their house salad is fresh, big portion size and has a really tasty...

Photo of Jill G.
Jill G.
7/27/2025

We absolutely love this place! We were in New Buffalo for a couple days & we ate there for lunch on Thursday & back for breakfast Friday. Beautiful seating area with windows & skylights by the...

Photo of Amy W.
Amy W.
11/15/2025

I had an amazing lunch truly a five-star meal. The cacio e pepe was spot-on. Loved it. The service was wonderful.

Photo of Maralyn O.
Maralyn O.
10/19/2024

The service was great, the food was delicious and didn't break my bank account, but I hate when they nail you for a "convenience fee".... I would rather leave that for the server. Also, a woman...

Owner verified
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesMichiganNew BuffaloBrewster's Italian Cafe

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.