Marc C.
8/5/2025
Ordered online. Super easy. Once again great experience. Trick must be to come when it's not busy, like now, Tuesday afternoon. Great pizza, no doubt about that. Huge slice of pizza $6.50 soda...
Benny DiCarta's
$
Closed
(52)
Photos
232 E Michigan Ave
Kalamazoo, MI 49007
Benny DiCarta's, rooted deeply in Kalamazoo, MI, pays homage to the city's proud history as the "Paper City." The establishment is a representation of local pride, with ties to family heritage going back to the Prohibition era, bringing a unique pizza experience to the Great Lakes region.
Specializing in large, flavorful pizzas, Benny DiCarta's menu features a variety of specialty toppings and partners beautifully with their playful community initiatives, making pizza a fun part of local culture. The large 28-inch pies are particularly popular among locals and are meant to bring friends and family together for a memorable dining experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.552 reviewsRalph M.
11/7/2025
The pizza by the slice is amazing! I stopped by there when working at the Kalamazoo event center and was very happy with the pizza.
Katy C.
8/4/2023
Pizza slices the size of your head. That's what you can expect at Benny DiCarta's! I stopped in recently and got a slice for lunch. Their whole pizzas are 28" in diameter and if you eat an entire...
Marianne G.
5/18/2023
Stopped here between bars one Friday night for some drunken eats. The slices are the size of your head - really though, from my personal experience this is the biggest piece of pizza I have ever...
John 7.
6/29/2025
Would 100% eat again and would recommend to anyone! The hot honey on top made my pepperoni pizza amazing. The staff was very friendly and my wife and I would eat again in a heartbeat.
See a problem?
