Heidi A.
4/16/2025
Stopped at Bay Pizzeria for the 1st time today. We ordered Cudighi subs, club sub and Italian sub, Lg order olive oil, garlic-parm breadsticks and a couple ready to go slices of pizza. It was all...
Bay Pizzeria
Closed
(5)
Photos
100 S Cedar St
Suttons Bay, MI 49682
Bay Pizzeria in Suttons Bay, MI, is a welcoming establishment offering a variety of handcrafted pizzas and sandwiches for any occasion. The philosophy at Bay Pizzeria centers around the use of quality, locally-sourced ingredients to create delicious pizzas from scratch. From the handmade dough to the house-made sauce, attention to detail is evident in every bite.
Choose from a selection of specialty pizzas like the Deluxe with pepperoni, ham, bacon, mushrooms, onions, and green pepper, or the Meat Lovers loaded with pepperoni, ham, bacon, sausage, cudighi, and meatball. Not just limited to pizzas, Bay Pizzeria also serves up mouthwatering sandwiches such as the Cudighi Sandwich, a unique Upper Peninsula classic, and hearty calzones resembling a U.P. Pizza Pasty.
For those looking for lighter options, fresh salads like the Garden or Greek are available, made with care and attention to freshness. With delivery offered within 10 miles, Bay Pizzeria ensures that their handcrafted food can be enjoyed in the comfort of your own home, making every meal a delightful experience.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
3.55 reviewsDerrell S.
7/19/2025
Pizza was burnt on bottom and the bread sticks were very dry and hard to bite into they were kinda of burnt too. A totally different pizza than the first time we ate there.
Dalene W.
4/16/2025
The best club sub I have ever had. Twice the meat and great service. My husband had the Cudighi sub which was excellent also.
Traveler M.
10/7/2024
The food was fantastic! The customer service was great and the restaurant was clean. Our entire group was happy with everything. I look forward to resting here again.
Ned O.
1/17/2025
Undercooked pie every time. Baked subs are cold still and Gross. Not a fan but the pie is put together correctly and the dough is better than across the street. Stop using baking screens ffs.
See a problem?
