Mindy L.
6/26/2013
I'm surprised at the reviews from last summer - really sound more like they are based on service and cost, but not the ice cream itself. While both are important, for sure...I am basing this...
Stars Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt
$$
(17)
Photos
[1 - 299] Straight Wharf
Nantucket, MA 02554
Stars Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt is a charming dessert shop nestled in the heart of Nantucket, MA. They offer a variety of delicious frozen treats to satisfy any sweet tooth.
With a cozy atmosphere and friendly service, Stars Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt is the perfect spot to enjoy a refreshing snack on a warm summer day. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cone or a custom frozen yogurt creation, they have something for everyone to enjoy.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.017 reviews
Chris V.
10/6/2025
Permanently closed for many years now, Yelp please update, we went there only to find it's now a fish and chips restaurant.
Katherine C.
7/22/2019
Great little ice cream place on the water. There are plenty of ice cream shops In Nantucket, but this one is tucked away with a perfect spot on the water. Sit and eat your ice cream on the dock...
Maria-Elena T.
9/4/2018
Got two scoops- the coconut and a rocky road knock off (can't remember the name). Sugar cone was crunchy. I tasted a few flavors before deciding. Ice cream was creamy and delish. I felt like a...
Dan R.
8/14/2012
Where do I start? How about $4.95 for a regular cone. Want sprinkles/jimmies- that's a buck extra. Flavor selection - minimal. And the attitude behind the counter wasn't very good, the guy spent...
See a problem?
