George H.
7/20/2023
Stopped at Sibbies pizza for a take out pizza. I'd had their grinders previously (which are great) so it was time to try the pizza. One of the things I like about this spot is that it's...
Sibie's Pizza
$
Closed
(70)
Photos
481 West St
Amherst, MA 01002
We are a family owned pizza shop located in South Amherst and are proud to be the oldest pizza place in Amherst run by its original owners. Our pizza is crafted from a family recipe, hand-tossed and topped with fresh, whole ingredients. Our dough and sauce are made fresh, every day. Top priorities: Customer satisfaction and creating quality, consistent products. Try our new vegan or gluten-free pies. “Locally-sourced & socially conscious.”
Also at this address
Reviews
4.070 reviews
Dan K.
11/16/2024
I've been getting pizza from this place for 18 years. This place quietly has the best pizza and calzones in Amherst--I've tried 'em all.. They take note of their ingredients, and the crust is...
Joe S.
9/4/2023
Pizza and subs are always high quality and quite delicious. One of my favorite pizza places. Also love the veggie burger bomb.
Clayton C.
9/8/2023
I've been buying Pizza at Sibies for about 8 years. It's been consistently good pizza... especially the crust. Until this summer. I'm not sure what happened, but I've been served absolutely...
Lizado L.
3/21/2023
Surprisingly the most outstanding item on the menu is the chicken tender appetizer which was for the kids but stolen by the grownups, and the 4 cheese pizza is delicious. The other pizzas are ok...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.