Jim G.
5/1/2025
Great spot for a fresh homemade sandwich Quality ingredients and a nice local vibe Highly recommend
Portly Pilgrim
$
Open
(28)
Photos
170 Water St
Plymouth, MA 02360
The Portly Pilgrim is a newly established sandwich shop located in the historic town of Plymouth, Massachusetts. Offering a delectable menu of hand-carved turkey, slow-braised corned beef, smoked beef brisket, fresh lobster, and more, this eatery is a haven for those seeking a satisfying meal.
With their signature sandwich, The Portly Pilgrim, featuring a double-decker day-after-Thanksgiving feast, complete with hand-carved turkey breast, Nana's stuffing, cranberry bread, and a slice of gravy-bread, this sandwich shop is sure to leave patrons stuffed and satisfied.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.528 reviews
Janet D.
10/12/2025
A no frills counter service excellent sandwich shop. We didn't have a long wait because there wasn't anyone ahead of us. Anyone after us had to wait in line outside the shop. Owner runs a one-man...
Frederick C.
10/11/2025
Visiting Plymouth and found this cozy little place with a great sounding menu. Definitely a grab and go place, just enough room to order and move aside so the next person behind you can order. I...
Jean M.
8/26/2025
So i wanted to love this place so many options they all sounded good. Until I sat there and watched the sandwich get made. The amount of butter put on that sandwich could give anyone a heart...
Timothy W.
10/8/2025
Stopped on a rainy afternoon. Cute little spot with amazing sandwiches. Hidden in a little courtyard. Enjoyed two sandwiches from the water front park across the street.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.