Colin P.
10/4/2025
The pizza was amazing. Crust was fantastic, highly recommend the pepperoni. Grab a pie and head to the beach!
Pizzeria Gemelle
$
Closed
(43)
Photos
2 E Chestnut St
Nantucket, MA 02554
Step into the cozy realm of Pizzeria Gemelle, a charming spot nestled in the heart of Nantucket, MA. Here, a group of pizza enthusiasts comes together to craft delectable Neapolitan-inspired pizzas that will tantalize your taste buds.
Indulge in our unique array of budget-friendly wines, delectable Southern desserts, fresh salads, and delightful sides that complement our star attraction—mouthwatering pizzas. At Pizzeria Gemelle, every dish is prepared with passion and creativity, promising a culinary experience like no other in this quaint seaside town.
Generated using this place's available information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.043 reviews
Jason B.
8/30/2025
Pizza was very mediocre. And the clerk was a little entitled. Total came to $6.42 and I gave $7, and he didn't give me the change. I was planning on putting the change in the tip can anyway,...
Lily S.
8/31/2025
I've heard people call this a hole in the wall... that would be a kind term for what's hardly a functioning establishment. All who work there have a serious attitude issue - no one was helpful,...
Ofer B.
10/12/2024
Hole in the wall, with a handful of seats, banging out fresh pizzas from a wood burning oven that were delicious, shockingly had a table white wine bottle that cost less than a pizza obviously...
Trish H.
4/25/2025
I am baffled that this place only had 4/5 on Yelp. Honestly, incredible pizza. And that's coming from an NYC pizza snob. Love it.
See a problem?
