Daniel L.
10/26/2025
There are a boatload of ice cream shoppes in and around this part of Oak Bluffs, but only one had the name that drew me in: Mad Martha. I had hoped to discern whether she was mad (supervillain),...
Mad Martha's Ice Cream
Permanently closed
(79)
Photos
12 E Circuit Ave
Oak Bluffs, MA 02557
Mad Martha's Ice Cream, a beloved local institution on Martha's Vineyard, traces its origins to a little girl named Martha who transformed frozen cream into delectable ice cream, captivating island residents with her fresh flavors. Since then, the shop has become a staple for both locals and tourists, offering a wide variety of homemade ice cream made with the freshest local ingredients.
With three locations across Martha's Vineyard, Mad Martha's continues to celebrate the joy of ice cream, inviting visitors to indulge in a sweet treat while soaking up the picturesque surroundings. The shop is also proud to be the official ice cream of the MV Sharks, creating a true community connection through their delicious offerings.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.079 reviews
Troy S.
9/25/2025
Nice variety, they serve coffee, too. Flavor of the month and rotating ice cream flavors. Cone or cup. Friendly service. Island prices. Cute decor. Limited seating with 4 tables. They sell...
Elizabeth S.
6/24/2024
This is my favorite island ice cream joint. I think the flavors and creaminess of the ice cream are what you would expect and they really pack the ice cream onto your cone. Staff are friendly and...
Erika C.
8/11/2024
Great place to cool off on a hot summer day! Very nice and clean inside and the staff were very knowledgeable of all the flavors. You can try samples before choosing your flavor and Mud Pie was...
Linda H.
5/28/2024
Had to try..bc this seems to me an MV staple. With their collab with back door donuts went with the Apple fritter flavor ice cream...which was different. Def have never had a donut flavored ice...
See a problem?
