Joanne C.
7/20/2025
Delicious lobster roll. Amazing flavor. Big chunks of lobster. Sticker shock at $32 for 1 sandwich (I've been away from New England for many years) but what else can you expect on the island?! It...
MacPhail's Corner Cafe
$
Closed
(50)
Photos
18 Dock St
Edgartown, MA 02539
Also at this address
Reviews
4.050 reviewsCharles L.
8/10/2025
Had lobster roll and fried chicken sandwich. Both come with potato chips. Lobster roll was quite good. Chicken sandwich was ok. Fast service. Limited seating.
Natalie C.
7/9/2022
Best and LARGEST lobster roll on the island. Hefty warm roll filled with chilled, large chunks of lobster salad. So amazing I wanted to go back for another. If you really want to treat yourself,...
Winter B.
7/10/2022
MacPhails is a small, casual spot but don't look past it! They serve breakfast and lunch all day as well as coffee and pastries. The breakfast burrito was amazing, it had tater tots, eggs, bacon,...
Christiane M.
8/3/2023
very chill vibe here which is nice. super casual and easy take out. caprese was yum. other friends got popcorn chicken which was also enjoyed.
See a problem?
