Goodnight Fatty

$$
Open
yelp logo

(207)

Call
Website

Photos

1 Washington St
Salem, MA 01970
+1 (978) 822-2277
http://goodnightfatty.com
Each weekend, we sling a new line-up of three flavors of Fatties (that's what we call cookies) packed with nostalgia. Fatties are thicc, smashed with quality ingredients, and served right out of the oven. We work hard to come up with something fresh each week that gets you pumped for the weekend. Join us every Sunday for breakfast as Good Morning Chubby. There’s breakfast… and then there are Chubbies: one-handed bundles of breakfast extravaganza. Start your Sunday with us, and the rest of the day will simply fall into place We call the historic Andrew-Safford Carriage House our home. Formerly a frozen yogurt shop, the Carriage House is closely located near many of Salem’s downtown restaurants and popular attractions, such as the Witch Museum, Salem Common, and Hawthorne Hotel.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5207 reviews
Photo of Erika H.
Erika H.
10/9/2025

As you as you arrive you notice what looks like an ice cream truck/ can with skeletons inside and outside lol sounds weird but makes this location stand out! The inside is small, but full of...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Molly M.
Molly M.
10/6/2025

I'm into fitness: fitness cookie into my mouth!! These cookies are crazy good! The one that surprised me the most was their cereal cookie! I don't like sweet cereal so I didn't expect to even...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Jenny R.
Jenny R.
9/22/2025

Goodnight Fatty is such a fun Salem gem! Every weekend they roll out different cookie flavors ("Fatties"), and they are always warm, gooey, and packed with mix-ins. The lineup changes often, which...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Maddie L.
Maddie L.
9/29/2025

Best place on earth. They have the best cookies I've ever had. I genuinely eat them every time and I'm confused how they get the same consistency and greatness but still do so many different...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Michelle M.
Michelle M.
7/10/2025

I've been enjoying Goodnight Fatty since I was a college student at SSU, and when they had their original location in the alley. Their old location was bright inside and had high tops and board...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

TOUS les JOURS
Eating places, Pizza restaurants

TOUS les JOURS

72
•
$$
"I literally have been thinking about the Croque monsieur lately after getting it a couple months ago. SO. GOOD. the bread is kind of sweet and the cheese on the outside is so good with seasoning...."
photo of Hannah S.
Lady M Cake Boutique
Eating places, Pizza restaurants

Lady M Cake Boutique

264
•
$
"Lady M Cake Boutique is a well-known spot for upscale cakes, and this Newbury Street location fits right in. The staff were super friendly and helpful, giving us a rundown of what slices were left..."
photo of Nick S.
TOUS les JOURS
Eating places, Pizza restaurants

TOUS les JOURS

83
•
$$
"Very tasty and good quality product, the strawberry cloud cake or the chocolate cloud cake, very good, but very expensive, too!"
photo of Brigitte E.
United States›Massachusetts›Salem›Goodnight Fatty

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.