Coney Island Ice Cream

Permanently closed
yelp logo

(45)

Photos

1284 Washington St
West Newton, MA 02465

Reviews

yelp logo
3.545 reviews
Photo of Hubert H.
Hubert H.
7/7/2017

Really nice business; I had a ham sandwich with swiss cheese and mixed greens. Might have been nicer to have more greens, though you could probably request that. Also had a half ginger half...

Photo of Brody M.
Brody M.
3/16/2019

Worst hospitality I've ever witnessed. I walked into there thinking I was going to get some pretty good ice cream, but ended leaving without anything. As soon as I get into the place the owner...

Photo of Katie C.
Katie C.
10/23/2017

Nah. Nope. Never again. The owner is a real jerk, no customer service what so ever. Prices are sky high. If you are into being treated like crap, super small servings of ice cream and outrageous...

Brian K.
2/18/2019

Great find for a weekday lunch. Fulvio and his wife were so nice and accommodating. The sandwiches were fresh and excellent. The ice cream was great. Be sure to stop in for a pleasant time.

Photo of Julia E.
Julia E.
3/31/2018

(my 7-year old niece wrote this because she loves the ice cream at this place. She gives 5 stars)

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesMassachusettsWest NewtonConey Island Ice Cream

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.