Chilmark Tavern

I struggle to leave reviews that are less than stellar as someone who has worked in restaurants for over 30 years. That said, I've rarely felt more of a late reservation burden than my wife and I...

Great food and service, mussels excellent. Surprised to see undisclosed $20 corkage fee on the bill. Never seen one in a byob restaurant. Still worth it, but the fee shouldn't be a surprise.

Came on a Monday night for a 5:30pm reservation with 3 girlfriends. We came on the early side because we wanted to watch the sunset on the beach after dinner. The dining room was pretty sparsely...

Not great. Cold boring bland bread, unremarkable salads, arid tasteless halibut, dry chicken. I usually don't post reviews but people should expect more from such a well known restaurant. Maybe...

We dined last week - 2 couples on MV and tried Chilmark Tavern... great choice The place is very appealing with a great vibe. Our server, a young Serbian lady was fantastic and everything we had...